Excellent
By Yar'
An excellent book. Read it first a couple years back and have reread it several times since. Definitely my favorite of the three.
Holly Black is amazing.
By NecroPanda
I love all of her books but this book should not be in children's fiction. Read this book years ago in high school and it is definitely teens or older.
Amazing!
By Joel Emory
A beautiful, amazing, simply enthralling book! Inspiring as well, Holly Black's great imagination at its best!
Absolutely Enthralling!
By vici ruthless
The only negative thing I can say about this book is that it ended. I'd give anything for Holly Black to write a sequel. Read it - you won't be disappointed.
I. WANT. MORE.
By Trixxxieee
This novel left me wanting, no needing to know more. What happens after? What what what?! I love this book it's incredible!!! SIX STARS. Plain and simple. Read this you won't regret it. I desperately hope Ms. Black writes more.
Beautiful, eerie, thrilling.
By Sarjysoxx
Holly black is my favorite author. Her stories of faeries are so different of those we've grown up with. Innocence is not the case. I love reading her books and I wish she would write more modern faerie tale novels!
Not for "children" as categorized
By GrigFamily
Older teens only. Drug usage, sex, and foul language permeate this book. Imaginative .... Would have had a broader audience without the D,S, and F.